Image: schwede-photodesign / Adobe Stock

Quick Hits

  • The retroactive protection against dismissal under Section 18 of the Federal Parental Benefit and Parental Leave Act (Bundeselterngeld- und Elternzeitgesetz (BEEG[SF1] )) applies anew before the start of each period of parental leave.
    The retroactive protection against termination pursuant to Section 18(1), sentence 2, of the BEEG begins no earlier than eight weeks before the start of parental leave that extends until the child reaches the age of three, or no earlier than fourteen weeks before the start of parental leave that falls between the child’s third birthday and the child’s eighth birthday.
    This also applies if employees request multiple periods of parental leave in a single written request.
    The special protection against dismissal applies regardless of a probationary period.

The Case—Parental Leave in Four Periods

An employee who was in the probationary period requested parental leave for several periods over a total of three years and intended to work part-time during the second period.

The employer confirmed the parental leave and agreed to the part-time work. After consulting with the staff council, the employer gave the employee notice of termination in accordance with standard procedure before the probationary period had expired. At that time, the employee was not in a parental leave period, but the next period was scheduled to begin in about five weeks. The employee subsequently filed an unfair dismissal claim, relying on the retroactive protection against termination applicable during parental leave.

The Decision—Protection Against Termination Even Between Periods

The lower courts, the Münster Labor Court (Arbeitsgericht (ArbG) Münster) and Germany’s Hamm State Labor Court (Landesarbeitsgericht (LAG) Hamm, Ref. No. 11 SLa 394/25), ruled in favor of the employee. The employer’s appeal to the BAG was also unsuccessful. The BAG ruled that the termination was invalid, thereby upholding the decision of the LAG Hamm.

Under Section 18 of the BEEG, an employer generally may not dismiss an employee from the point in time at which parental leave has been requested. In the case of parental leave lasting until the child reaches the age of three, this retroactive protection begins no earlier than eight weeks before the start of parental leave. In the BAG’s view, this retroactive effect applies not only before the first period but before each individual period of parental leave if the employee has divided their parental leave into several periods.

The fact that the employee had requested all parental leave periods in one letter did not change the outcome. Nor did it matter that the employee was still in the probationary period. According to the BAG, the BEEG does not provide an exception for employment relationships that are still within the six-month waiting period under the German Protection Against Dismissal Act (Kündigungsschutzgesetz (KSchG)), before general dismissal protection applies. The court found that lawmakers intended to provide broad protection during this particular phase of life.

Takeaways

In cases of split parental leave, the special protection against dismissal under Section 18 BEEG may apply anew before each segment. The decisive point is not only whether the employee is already on parental leave when the dismissal is issued, but also whether the dismissal falls within the statutory advance protection period before a parental leave period begins.

The probationary period does not change this, because Section 18 BEEG applies regardless of whether the waiting period under the KSchG has been completed.

The decision does not make dismissals connected with parental leave categorically impossible; in special cases, the competent authority may declare a dismissal permissible under Section 18(1), sentence 4 BEEG, but without such a declaration, a dismissal during the protected period is invalid.

Under German law, employees may generally split parental leave into up to three periods. Additional periods usually require the employer’s consent. If the employer accepts the split, or if the employee has otherwise made a valid parental leave request, the BAG’s decision means that special dismissal protection starts again before each parental leave period.

Dr. Merle Steinhuber is an associate in the Berlin office of Ogletree Deakins.

Lela Salman, a law clerk in Ogletree Deakins’ Berlin office, contributed to this article.

Author

Topics


Browse More Insights

Sign up to receive emails about new developments and upcoming programs.

Sign Up Now